Developing three hybrid machine learning algorithms for predicting the mechanical properties of plastic concrete samples with different geometries

Document Type : Research Article


1 Young Researchers and Elite Club, Rasht Branch, Islamic Azad University, Rasht, Iran

2 Department of Civil Engineering, Sirjan University of Technology, Sirjan, Iran

3 PhD candidate of Geotechnical & Geo-Environmental Engineering, Southern Illinois University Carbondale


Plastic concrete is an engineering material, which is commonly used for construction of cut-off walls to prevent water seepage under the dam. This type of concrete shows great promise    to satisfy the requirements of the strength, stiffness and permeability for remedial cut-off wall construction. This paper aims to explore three hybrid machine learning algorithms including Artificial Neural Network (ANN), Support Vector Machine (SVM) and Adaptive Neuro-Fuzzy Inference System (ANFIS) optimized with Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) to predict the compressive and splitting tensile strength of plastic concretes. To this end, data were collected from different sources and data gaps were covered by extra experimental tests and finally, 387 data for compressive strength and 107 data for splitting tensile strength were gathered for modeling. This study shows that ANN-PSO is superior to SVM-PSO and ANFIS-PSO in case of predicting compressive as well as splitting tensile strength   of plastic concretes. The coefficient of determination (R2) in case of ANN-PSO for both training and testing sets is more than 0.95. Results of this study can be used to predict the compressive and splitting tensile strength of plastic concretes with regards to constituent materials and specimen geometry of plastic concrete.


Main Subjects

[1]  T.W. Kahl, J.L. Kauschinger, E.B. Perry, Repair, Evaluation, Maintenance, and Rehabilitation Research Program: Plastic Concrete Cutoff Walls for Earth Dams, DTIC Document, 1991.
[2]   L.M. Hu, D.Y. Gao, Y.Z. Li, S.Q. Song, Analysis of the Influence of Long Curing Age on the Compressive Strength of Plastic Concrete, in: Advanced Materials Research, Trans Tech Publ, 2012, pp. 200-203.
[3]   ICOLD, Filling materials for watertight cut off walls. Bulletin, in, International Committee of Large Dams, Paris, France, 1995.
[4]  S.L. Garvin, C.S. Hayles, The chemical compatibility of cement–bentonite cut-off wall material, Construction and Building Materials, 13(6) (1999) 329-341.
[5]  D. Koch, Bentonites as a basic material for technical base liners and site encapsulation cut-off walls, Applied Clay Science, 21(1) (2002) 1-11.
[6]  M. Naderi, Effect of different constituent materials on the properties of plastic concrete, International Journal of Civil Engineering, 3(1) (2005) 10-19.
[7]  D.Y. Gao, K. Yan, L.M. Hu, S.Q. Song, Influence of bentonite types on the properties of plastic concrete Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering, 28(3) (2009) 112-116.
[8]  A. Tahershamsi, A. Bakhtiyari, N. Binazadeh, Effects of clay mineral type and content on compressive strength of plastic concrete (In Persian), Iranian Journal of Mining Engineering, 4(7) (2009) 35-42.
[9]  G.Q. Ding, L.H. Jiang, H.Q. Chu, Q. Zhu, Influences of types and dosage of bentonite on properties of plastic concrete, Advances in Science and Technology of Water Resources, 31(2) (2011) 34-37.
[10] A. Pashazadeh, M. Chekani Azar, Estimating an Appropriate Plastic Concrete Mixing Design for Cutoff Walls to Control Leakage under the Earth Dam, Journal of Basic and Applied Scientific Research, 1(9) (2011) 1295-1299.
[11] A.A. Ata, T.N. Salem, N.M. Elkhawas, Properties of soil–bentonite– cement bypass mixture for cutoff walls, Construction and Building Materials, 93 (2015) 950-956.
[12] J.L. García-Siñeriz, M.V. Villar, M. Rey, B. Palacios, Engineered barrier of bentonite pellets and compacted blocks: State after reaching saturation, Engineering Geology, 192 (2015) 33-45.
[13] P. Zhang, Q.Y. Guan, Q.F. Li, Mechanical Properties of Plastic Concrete Containing Bentonite, Research Journal of Applied Sciences, Engineering and Technology, 5(4) (2013) 1317-1322.
[14] Y. Yu, J. Pu, K. Ugai, Study of mechanical properties of soil-cement mixture for a cut-off wall, Soils Found, 37(4) (1997) 93-103.
[15] H. Abbaslou, A.R. Ghanizadeh, A.T. Amlashi, The compatibility of bentonite/sepiolite plastic concrete cut-off wall material, Construction and Building Materials, 124 (2016) 1165-1173.
[16] S. Hinchberger, J. Weck, T. Newson, Mechanical and hydraulic characterization of plastic concrete for seepage cut-off walls, Canadian Geotechnical Journal, 47(4) (2010) 461-471.
[17] L.M. Hu, stress-strain relation model and failure criterion of plastic concrete under compression (In Chinese), Material processing engineering school of materials science and engineering, Zhengzhou, China, 2012.
[18] A. Mahboubi, A. Ajorloo, Experimental study of the mechanical behavior of plastic concrete in triaxial compression, Cement and concrete research, 35(2) (2005) 412-419.
[19] A. Mahboubi, M. Anari, Effects of Mixing Proportions and Sample Age on Mechanical Properties of Plastic Concrete; An Experimental Study, in: First international conference on concrete technology, Tabriz, Iran, 2009.
[20] Y.P. Pisheh, S.M.M. Hosseini, Stress-strain behavior of plastic concrete using monotonic triaxial compression tests, Journal of Central South University, 19(4) (2012) 1125-1131.
[21] J.S. Chou, C.K. Chiu, M. Farfoura, I. Al-Taharwa, Optimizing the prediction accuracy of concrete compressive strength based on a comparison of data-mining techniques, Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering, 25(3) (2010) 242-253.
[22] F.F. Martins, A. Camões, Prediction of compressive strength of concrete containing fly ash using data mining techniques, (2013).
[23] M. Ebrahimi, A.A. Niknafs, Increasing Cement Strength Using Data Mining Techniques, in: International Conference Data Mining, Civil and Mechanical Engineering (ICDMCME), Bali (Indonesia), 2015
[24] N.N. Eldin, A.B. Senouci, Measurement and prediction of the strength of rubberized concrete, Cement and Concrete Composites, 16(4) (1994) 287-298.
[25] M.H. Fazel Zarandi, I.B. Türksen, J. Sobhani, A.A. Ramezanianpour, Fuzzy polynomial neural networks for approximation of the compressive strength of concrete, Applied Soft Computing, 8(1) (2008) 488-498.
[26] D.K. Kim, J.J. Lee, J.H. Lee, S.K. Chang, Application of Probabilistic Neural Networks for Prediction of Concrete Strength, Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, 17(3) (2005) 353-362.
[27]  J.J. Lee, D. Kim, S.K. Chang, C.F.M. Nocete, An improved application technique of the adaptive probabilistic neural network for predicting concrete strength, Computational Materials Science, 44(3) (2009) 988- 998.
[28] R. Madandoust, R. Ghavidel, N. Nariman Zadeh, Evolutionary design of generalized GMDH-type neural network for prediction of concrete compressive strength using UPV, Computational Materials Science, 49(3) (2010) 556-567.
[29] R. Madandoust, J.H. Bungey, R. Ghavidel, Prediction of the concrete compressive strength by means of core testing using GMDH-type neural network and ANFIS models, Computational Materials Science, 51(1) (2012) 261-272.
[30] J. Kasperkiewicz, J. Racz, A. Dubrawsk, HPC Strength Prediction Using Artificial Neural Network, Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering, 9(4) (1995) 279-284.
[31] İ.B. Topçu, M. Sarıdemir, Prediction of properties of waste AAC aggregate concrete using artificial neural network, Computational Materials Science, 41(1) (2007) 117-125.
[32] S. Subaşı, Prediction of mechanical properties of cement containing class C fly ash by using artificial neural network and regression technique, Sci Res Essay, 4(4) (2009) 289-297.
[33] S.J.S. Hakim, J. Noorzaei, M. Jaafar, M. Jameel, M. Mohammadhassani, Application of artificial neural networks to predict compressive strength of high strength concrete, Int. J. Phys. Sci, 6(5) (2011) 975-981.
[34] A. Nazari, H. Hajiallahyari, A. Rahimi, H. Khanmohammadi, M. Amini, Prediction compressive strength of Portland cement-based geopolymers by artificial neural networks, Neural Comput & Applic, (2012) 1-9.
[35] S. Kostić, D. Vasović, Prediction model for compressive strength of basic concrete mixture using artificial neural networks, Neural Comput & Applic, 26(5) (2015) 1005-1024.
[36] J.F. Moretti, C.R. Minussi, J.L. Akasaki, C.F. Fioriti, J.L.P. Melges, M.M. Tashima, Prediction of modulus of elasticity and compressive strength of concrete specimens by means of artificial neural networks, Acta Scientiarum. Technology, 38(1) (2016) 65-70.
[37] A. Sadrmomtazi, J. Sobhani, M. Mirgozar, Modeling compressive strength of EPS lightweight concrete using regression, neural network and ANFIS, Construction and Building Materials, 42 (2013) 205-216.
[38] J. Sobhani, M. Khanzadi, A. Movahedian, Support vector machine for prediction of the compressive strength of no-slump concrete, Computers and Concrete, 11(4) (2013) 337-350.
[39] S. Tesfamariam, H. Najjaran, Adaptive network–fuzzy inferencing to estimate concrete strength using mix design, Journal of materials in civil engineering, 19(7) (2007) 550-560.
[40] M.Y. Cheng, J.S. Chou, A.F. Roy, Y.W. Wu, High-performance concrete compressive strength prediction using time-weighted evolutionary fuzzy support vector machines inference model, Automation in Construction, 28 (2012) 106-115.
[41] S. Motamedi, S. Shamshirband, D. Petković, R. Hashim, Application of adaptive neuro-fuzzy technique to predict the unconfined compressive strength of PFA-sand-cement mixture, Powder Technology, 278 (2015) 278-285.
[42] S.S. Gilan, H.B. Jovein, A.A. Ramezanianpour, Hybrid support vector regression–Particle swarm optimization for prediction of compressive strength and RCPT of concretes containing metakaolin, Construction and Building Materials, 34 (2012) 321-329.
[43] Z. Yuan, L.N. Wang, X. Ji, Prediction of concrete compressive strength: Research on hybrid models genetic based algorithms and ANFIS, Advances in Engineering Software, 67 (2014) 156-163.
[44] A. Nazari, J.G. Sanjayan, Modelling of compressive strength of geopolymer paste, mortar and concrete by optimized support vector machine, Ceramics International, 41(9, Part B) (2015) 12164-12177.
[45] M. Nikoo, F. Torabian Moghadam, Ł. Sadowski, Prediction of concrete compressive strength by evolutionary artificial neural networks, Advances in Materials Science and Engineering, 2015 (2015).
[46] Y. Ayaz, A.F. Kocamaz, M.B. Karakoç, Modeling of compressive strength and UPV of high-volume mineral-admixtured concrete using rule-based M5 rule and tree model M5P classifiers, Construction and Building Materials, 94 (2015) 235-240.
[47] J. Kennedy, R.C. Eberhart, Particle swarm optimization, in: In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on neural networks, 1995, pp. 1942–1948.
[48] S.S. Haykin, Neural networks: a comprehensive foundation, Tsinghua University Press, 2001.
[49] J.A. Freeman, D.M. Skapura, Neural Networks: Algorithms, Applications and Programming Techniques, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1992.
[50] D.E. Rumelhart, G.E. Hintont, R.J. Williams, Learning representations by back-propagating errors Nature, 323 (1986) 533-536.
[51] P. Werbos, Beyond regression: new tools for prediction and analysis in the behavioral sciences, Harvard University, Cambridge, 1974.
[52] V. Vapnik, S.E. Golowich, A. Smola, Support vector method for function approximation, regression estimation, and signal processing, Advances in neural information processing systems, (1997) 281-287. [53] V.N. Vapnik, V. Vapnik, Statistical learning theory, Wiley New York, 1998.
[54] J.S.R. Jang, ANFIS: adaptive-network-based fuzzy inference system, IEEE transactions on systems, man, and cybernetics, 23(3) (1993) 665- 685.
[55] J.S.R. Jang, C.T. Sun, E. Mizutani, Neuro-fuzzy and soft computing; a computational approach to learning and machine intelligence, (1997).
[56] T. Takagi, M. Sugeno, Fuzzy identification of systems and its applications to modeling and control, IEEE transactions on systems, man, and cybernetics, (1) (1985) 116-132.
[57] D.M. Moore, R.C. Reynolds, X-ray Diffraction and the Identification and Analysis of Clay Minerals, Oxford university press Oxford, 1989.
[58] ICOLD, Soil-Cement, in, International Committee of Large Dams, Paris, France, 1986.
[59] M. Fathinaz, Assessment the effect of bentonite and soil lateral pressure on the stress-strain behavior of plastic concrete cut-off walls (In Persian), Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Amirkabir University of Technology, Tehran, Iran, 1998.
[60] A. Bagheri, M. Abdi, M. Mombeyni, Increasing the formability of plastic concrete without reducing strength by optimizing the volume of bentonite and cement slurry in the mix (In Persian), in: 6th international conference of civil engineering, Isfahan University of Technology, Isfahan, Iran, 2003.
[61] Q.F. Li, P. Zhang, Experimental research on strength of plastic concrete (In Chinese), concrete, (5) (2006) 75-79.
[62] M. Shahbaznia, M. Shokrchizadeh, Mix design of plastic concrete cutoff wall of Reservoir Dam Project in Duiraj city, in: 2nd National Conference of Dam and Hydropower Plants, Iran Water Resources and Power Development Company, Tehran, Iran, 2008.
[63] A. Ajam, R. Mohajeri Borjghaleh, Evaluation the effect of water-cement ratio on the plastic concrete cutoff walls using in dams (In Persian), in: First national conference of structure-earthquake-geotechnic, 2010.
[64] B. Hamdollah, M. Khanmohammadi, Experimental study on the possibility of using plastic concretes containing silica fume in structural members, in: 2nd National Conference of Concrete, Tehran, Iran, 2010.
[65] S.Q. Song, D.Y. Gao, K. Yan, L.M. Hu, Influece of the cementitious materials on the strength of plastic concrete, Concrete, (6) (2010) 86-88.
[66] S.H. Mousavi, H.S. Kazran, M.F. Maghrebi, The use of plastic concrete with specified aggregate in the implementation of concrete lining (In Persian), in: First national conference on civil engineering, Zibakenar, Iran, 2012.
[67] E. Dabir, Experimental evaluation of the effect of bentonite on the compressive strength, modulus of elasticity and permeability of plastic concrete (In Persian), in: 15th national conference of civil engineering students, University of Urmia, Urmia, Iran, 2014.
[68] S. Azemi, Plastic concrete cutoff walls in earth dams: a perspective of arid environment clay mineral resources, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Sirjan Univesity of Technology, Sirjan, Iran, 2015.
[69] P. Zhang, Q.F. Li, Experimental Research on Tensile Strength of Plastic Concrete, Water Power, (2) (2008) 64-66.
[70] Q.Y. Guan, P. Zhang, Effect of Clay Dosage on Mechanical Properties of Plastic Concrete, in: Advanced Materials Research, Trans Tech Publ, 2011, pp. 664-667.
[71] K. Levenberg, A method for the solution of certain non-linear problems in least squares, Quarterly of applied mathematics, 2(2) (1944) 164-168.
[72] D.W. Marquardt, An algorithm for least-squares estimation of nonlinear parameters, Journal of the society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics, 11(2) (1963) 431-441.
[73] Y. Yang, Q. Zhang, A hierarchical analysis for rock engineering using artificial neural networks, Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering, 30(4) (1997) 207-222.